Blog

Why blocking a site works better than willpower

By Aditya Trivedi ·

Blocking a site works better than willpower because it moves the decision to a calm moment. You choose once, ahead of time, instead of fighting the same urge every few minutes. Research on self-control points the same way: people who change their situation tend to do better than people who try to resist. And the old idea that willpower is a tank that runs dry hasn’t held up in large replications.

We make Pawsome Family, a Chrome and Edge extension with a website blocker, so we have a reason to like this answer. We’ve linked every study, with its limits, so you can judge for yourself. Nothing here is medical advice.

Willpower isn’t a tank that runs dry

For years, a popular theory said self-control is a limited resource: use it up on one thing, and you have less for the next. Then large teams tried to repeat the key experiment. In 2016, 23 labs and 2,141 people found an effect close to zero. In 2021, 36 labs and 3,531 people found the same.

So you don’t give in at 4 pm because you’ve run out. The trouble is that every urge is a fresh decision, and a screen offers hundreds a day.

Screens are where self-control fails most

In a 2012 study, 205 adults reported their desires through the day, when their phones prompted them, for a week: 7,827 reports in all. Desires for media use, like checking a site or watching something, and for work were the ones people most often failed to resist. It relied on self-reports over one week, but it matches what most of us know.

Changing the situation works better than resisting

Psychologists Angela Duckworth, Tamar Gendler and James Gross argued in 2016 that changing your surroundings stops a temptation before it grows, and feels like less of a struggle than resisting in the moment. Their example: a student who goes to the library without a phone.

Their team then tested it. In two field experiments, students told to change their situation met their study goals more often over the next week than students told to resist, or given no strategy. A website blocker is that kind of change: the site isn’t there to resist.

Deciding ahead of time

Plan for the moment you’re tempted

Plans in the form “if this happens, I’ll do that” help people reach goals, including staying on track when distractions come up. A 2024 review of 642 tests found effects from small to medium-sized, and larger when the plan was a real “if, then” and had been rehearsed. For example: “If I open a new tab for no reason, I’ll close it and take a breath.”

How to put this to work

  1. Block before you need to. Set it up on a calm morning, not mid-scroll.
  2. Pick only the sites that get you. Two or three, not every site you’ve ever wasted time on. Not sure which? See how much time you spend on each website first.
  3. Match the block to the site. Always for sites with no upside, Days and times for work or study hours, a Daily limit for sites you want a little of.
  4. Make undoing take effort. With the plan, Lock means a site can be unblocked only on your Website blocker page, not with one click from the toolbar.
  5. Leave room for breaks. The workplace study is a reminder that blocking everything all day can backfire.
  6. Look again after a week, and loosen or tighten what you set.

For step-by-step setups, see blocking sites while you study and blocking a site during work hours.

What blocking can’t do

A browser blocker can be removed, and it won’t touch your phone. For blocks you can’t undo, see Cold Turkey vs a browser website blocker. And if focusing is hard most days, a blocker won’t fix that. A doctor or another qualified professional is the right person to talk to.

A website blocker with a dog in it

Pawsome Family’s website blocker blocks the sites you choose in Chrome and Edge: always, on the days and times you pick, or after a daily limit. Open one out of habit, and a calm page appears instead, with a small dog for company.

Free for 30 days, with no card needed.